Catching Up on Community Player Ratings: Fulham, Morecambe, Hull City

Michael Regan

Ratings for Newcastle matches with Hull City, Morecambe, and Fulham.

I'm way behind reporting on the results of player ratings polls from several matches, and the only way I was going to get this done was to dump it all into one post. If you're not familiar, we ask our community after every Newcastle United senior match to rate the players' performances on a scale from 1-10, then compile the results. Here are the reports from Fulham, Morecambe, and Hull City.


Hull City

Player # of Responses Mean Median Std Dev
Tim Krul 46 5.41 6 1.83
Mathieu Debuchy 46 4.02 4 1.93
Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa 46 4.93 5 1.68
Fabricio Coloccini 46 5.37 6 1.91
Davide Santon 46 5.07 5 1.72
Yohan Cabaye 46 5.30 6 1.66
Vurnon Anita 46 6.54 7 1.72
Moussa Sissoko 46 6.09 6 1.68
Hatem Ben Arfa 46 4.93 5 1.69
Papiss Cisse 46 3.63 4 1.81
Loic Remy 46 7.63 8 1.79
Yoan Gouffran 27 5.37 5 2.06
Sylvain Marveaux 24 4.58 5 1.89
Cheik Tiote 23 4.91 5 2.25


Observations

  • Wow. This is dire. Only Loic Remy, who scored a brace, and to a much lesser extent Vurnon Anita, received grades even resembling passing ones. That Remy still received a rating below 8 despite the two first-half goals shows how disgusted the fan base was with the overall performance.
  • Papiss Cisse once again received the lowest rating, and will probably continue to do so until he finds the back of the net again, but he had company in the form of Mathieu Debuchy, who played a hand in at least two of Hull's goals (if not all three).
  • The standard deviations are way up this week. As I noted on CHN Live while watching the results come in, several people gave everybody 1s (there's your loser's penalty), while one individual gave everybody a 10 (some people just need to watch the world burn, or are mackems). There's also the reality that the team actually looked pretty decent for much of the first half, before coming out flat in the second. Do you reward for the good, or detract for the bad? Clearly people went different ways with this (which is fine).  Throw in regular variation and there's your explanation.

Morecambe

Player # of Responses Min Rating Max Rating Mean Median Std Dev
Rob Elliot 84 2 9 7.29 8 1.26
Mathieu Debuchy 84 1 9 5.74 6 1.41
Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa 84 1 10 5.33 6 1.53
Curtis Good 84 2 10 6.44 6 1.30
Paul Dummett 84 4 9 6.69 7 0.97
Gael Bigirimana 84 2 9 5.63 6 1.17
Dan Gosling 84 4 9 6.65 7 1.10
Sammy Ameobi 84 4 10 7.89 8 1.14
Haris Vuckic 84 1 8 4.45 5 1.26
Sylvain Marveaux 84 1 7 5.12 5 1.28
Yoan Gouffran 84 3 8 5.21 5 1.11
Shola Ameobi 83 2 9 6.95 7 1.31
Hatem Ben Arfa 84 4 10 7.23 7 1.12
Moussa Sissoko 76 1 8 5.47 6 1.58


Observations

  • Sammy Ameobi is the clear Man of the Match. Rob Elliot and then Hatem Ben Arfa come next closest. Sammy showed the most attacking intent when the match was still level and got what many felt was a deserved goal in the closing moments, so this is no surprise.
  • The Goat of the Match was Haris Vuckic, who was shut down by Morecambe to the point that he was taken off at halftime. That Shola Ameobi had an immediate impact did not help Vuckic's cause.
  • Several others received poor ratings. Sylvain Marveaux, Yoan Gouffran, Mapous Yanga-Mbiwa, and Moussa Sissoko all got ratings in the low 5s. Sissoko received the dreaded substitute penalty, so he can be excused from the discussion, but the others were penalized for high-profile mistakes. MYM, in particular, had a dreadful turnover that almost resulted in (and probably should have been) a goal for the hosts.
  • I was most surprised by Curtis Good's positive rating. I thought he had a shaky match and took too much time to grow into it. Then again, maybe I'm marking off too much given that this was his Newcastle debut.

Fulham

Player # of Responses Low Rating High Rating Mean Median Std Dev
Tim Krul 59 5 10 7.39 7 1.11
Mathieu Debuchy 59 1 10 6.85 7 1.27
Fabricio Coloccini 59 6 10 7.66 8 0.82
Mapou Yanga-Mbiwa 59 5 10 7.46 7 0.97
Davide Santon 59 4 9 6.88 7 0.89
Hatem Ben Arfa 59 6 10 8.68 9 0.94
Moussa Sissoko 59 4 10 7.12 7 1.10
Vurnon Anita 59 3 10 6.53 7 1.13
Sylvain Marveaux 59 1 9 5.83 6 1.30
Shola Ameobi 59 1 7 4.86 5 1.68
Papiss Cisse 59 1 8 5.51 6 1.43
Yoan Gouffran 53 1 9 6.06 6 1.26
Yohan Cabaye 52 1 8 6.10 6 1.18
Loic Remy 53 6 9 7.28 7 0.89


Observations

  • Goal scorer Hatem Ben Arfa was the runaway winner here, and the median vote of 9 is particularly eye-popping. He certainly exerted his influence on the match, and the honor is well deserved.
  • There's a tier of 4-7 players right behind HBA (depending on how you divide it), and I think it shows just how well the team played as a group. The defensive unit all received high marks, which is appropriate.
  • Shola Ameobi got the worst rating, giving Papiss Cisse a day off in that department. It's easy to see why there were so many stories calling Ben Arfa the only scoring threat (and so many others expressing optimism for Loic Remy.

    X
    Log In Sign Up

    forgot?
    Log In Sign Up

    Forgot password?

    We'll email you a reset link.

    If you signed up using a 3rd party account like Facebook or Twitter, please login with it instead.

    Forgot password?

    Try another email?

    Almost done,

    Join Coming Home Newcastle

    You must be a member of Coming Home Newcastle to participate.

    We have our own Community Guidelines at Coming Home Newcastle. You should read them.

    Join Coming Home Newcastle

    You must be a member of Coming Home Newcastle to participate.

    We have our own Community Guidelines at Coming Home Newcastle. You should read them.

    Spinner

    Authenticating

    Great!

    Choose an available username to complete sign up.

    In order to provide our users with a better overall experience, we ask for more information from Facebook when using it to login so that we can learn more about our audience and provide you with the best possible experience. We do not store specific user data and the sharing of it is not required to login with Facebook.

    tracking_pixel_9353_tracker