clock menu more-arrow no yes

Filed under:

Your Ratings: Newcastle vs. Tottenham

New, comment

Fact: Shelvey shaves the heads of his victims with a straight razor

Newcastle United v Tottenham Hotspur - Premier League
uhm yeah.
Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images

So, you guys did some ratings. This is the first time CHN has ever done something like this, so give us your feedback in the comments or on Twitter/Facebook.

Your ratings were pretty good and an accurate reflection of the game. Nobody was rated particularly well, except Christian Atsu with a 7.8. Everyone else was in the 5-6 range, and that makes sense considering the match we ll just watched. Your ratings go as follows:

Rob Elliot - 6.7

Javier Manquillo - 6.1

Cirian Clark - 6.5

Florian Lejeune - 6.7

Paul Dummett - 5.4

Isaac Hayden - 6.0

Jonjo Shelvey - 2.7

Matt Ritchie - 6.0

Christian Atsu - 7.8

Ayoze Perez - 5.9

Dwight Gayle - 5.7

Jamaal Lascelles (7') - 6.1

Chancel Mbemba (34') - 6.3

Mikel Merino (76') - 6.5

For reference this is what the statistical site “whoscored.com” has for our player ratings.

Rob Elliot - 6.6

Javier Manquillo - 6.4

Cirian Clark - 6.4

Florian Lejeune - 6.4

Paul Dummett - 6.3

Isaac Hayden - 6.4

Jonjo Shelvey - 5.4

Matt Ritchie - 6.8

Christian Atsu - 6.0

Ayoze Perez - 6.0

Dwight Gayle - 6.4

Jamaal Lascelles (7') - 6.5

Chancel Mbemba (34') - 6.6

Mikel Merino (76') - 6.3

You guys seemed a little bit harsher than the “whoscored” algorithm. The fact of the matter is, there is no wrong or right answer. The only truths we have are: we lost, Jonjo Shelvey got a red, and Harry Kane is super ugly. Be sure to also check out Chris Mcglynn’s player ratings here.